Which Medicare Supplement plan (Medigap) offers the best value for most seniors, and why?
Answered by 24 licensed agents
Plan G is usually the best value for most seniors. It covers almost everything except the Part B deductible, making it a solid choice for predictable costs and great coverage. It’s popular because it offers the most benefits without the high premiums of Plan F. (Which is only available for those eligible for Medicare before 1/1/2020) Plus, once the deductible is paid, there are no copays or surprise bills.
Answered by Abbie Choate on March 4, 2025
Broker Licensed in CA & NY
Medicare Supplement Plan G is my top pick for most seniors in 2025, covering all gaps in Original Medicare—like the Part B 20% coinsurance and the $257 deductible—delivering robust protection without surprise costs, which I’ve always valued from my years in this field. When Plan F was still open to new enrollees before January 1, 2020, it was my go-to because it handled every expense, including that Part B deductible, but now Plan G steps in with nearly identical coverage at a more affordable premium—averaging $130 to $150 monthly for a 65-year-old, depending on your area and insurer. I prefer G over options like N because it avoids copays and keeps your expenses steady, making it a practical, comprehensive choice for the long haul.
Answered by Brian Moore on March 27, 2025
Broker Licensed in OH
Depend on where the member lives, what they are looking for, price, carrier & if the members are looking for ancillary benefits ( dental, vision, OTC, food.....)
Answered by Melonie Wood on March 25, 2025
Agent Licensed in FL & AL
Both Plan G and Plan N offer great coverage for OUT of pocket Expenses and deductibles and depending on the company are generally reasonably priced! Before making any decisions get all the FACTS of coverage and costs!
This is not a cookie counter answer for all seniors based on their health and desired premiums, co-pays, deductibles and future rate increases. As of Jan 1, 2020, Medicare Supplements Plan C and Plan F were no longer available to new to Medicare seniors (a.k.a. Turning 65). There are still many others supplements available in most states. Some retirees will opt for Plan G, while others may opt for Plan N or Plan High Deductible G.
Answered by Christopher Boyd on March 4, 2025
Agent Licensed in IN, KY, MI, OH, PA & TN
If you started receiving or were eligible to receive Medicare prior to year 2020, than a Plan F Supplement or a High Deductible Plan F Supplement is best. If you were eligible or receiving Medicare after January 1, 2020, than a Plan G Supplement or a High Deductible Plan G Supplement is your best value. These four options are the only plans that cover all the part of Medicare 100% including Medicare Part B excess charges.
Answered by Thomas Ashton on March 29, 2025
Broker Licensed in FL, AL, AZ & 6 other states
plan G because it it limits your out of pocket medical expenses to an affordable annual deductible set by medicare
Answered by Ray McCauley on March 27, 2025
Broker Licensed in CA, AZ, FL & ID, NV, SC & TN
This all depends on specific client needs as well as finances. Medicare is never one size fits all plan.
Answered by Nikki Rowland on April 2, 2025
Broker Licensed in SC & NC
It depends on where you live and your age for the most part - so it's best to do a needs assessment and then shop around for the best plan rates as they are standardized by the Federal Government and can be used anywhere in the US that a doctor takes Medicare Assignment.
Answered by Soledad Ramirez on March 12, 2025
Broker Licensed in CA, AZ, NV & WA
This is a great question, one I get a lot. It's an easy question in theory, but not so easy to answer. Each client has needs, preferences, and experiences that will shape the decision they make, and it very rarely comes down to just price. In addition, geographic considerations and insurance company policies also play a key role in this process.
Medicare supplement plans (Medigap Plans) K, L, and M are available, but because these plans involve cost-sharing, some of them significant, consumer preferences lead to wider usage of plans G and N.
In a nutshell: Plan G does not require co-payments, covers Part B Excess charges, but will generally cost a bit more. Plan N will have co-payments, does not cover Part B excess, but will typically come at a lower price.
No easy answers. I would highly recommend consulting with a licensed and certified Medicare agent to help determine which plan would be right for you.
Answered by Bill Filer on March 26, 2025
Agent Licensed in MO, GA, KS & TN
Each plan is actuarially equal. Most Medigap plans have a structure of plan A through H with the H plan being the most in benefits. Wisconsin and another State regulate Medigap benefit's by using up to five benefit riders that can be added to each Medigap policy.
We like Medigap plans offered by larger companies that would enjoy a significantly larger block of business. The bigger the block, the more likely unexpected large claims will be absorbed by the bigger blocks and rate increases can be better mitigated.
Answered by William Kravit on March 25, 2025
Agent Licensed in WI, AZ, CO & 9 other states
Plan G would be my first choice because of only having the Part B deductible of $257 to pay when using the plan. Once that is paid, then everything else is paid 100%. My second choice would be Plan N. Plan N is a slightly cheaper way to go, but you will still pay a Dr copay of $20 and ER copay of $50 once the Part B Deductible of $257 is met.
Answered by Renee Brown on March 27, 2025
Broker Licensed in FL, AL, AR & 32 other states
No matter which Medicare Supplement plan you enroll in the coverage is the same. If you choose a plan G, it is the same coverage with every carrier. What to look for when enrolling in a Medicare Supplement plan is (1) monthly premium (2) financial rating of the company (3) and how long they have been in business. Make sure whoever you speak to can look at multiple carriers.
Answered by Kelsey Hentzen on March 31, 2025
Broker Licensed in KS & MO
It all depends on the seniors needs, everyone has different needs and has a different budget. Plan G is the best and most comprehensive plan but cost a bit more than other plans.
Answered by Don Hudson on April 1, 2025
Broker Licensed in FL
It's kind of a loaded question, but if we're talking in terms of what's available to seniors nowadays, it's hard to beat the Plan G. Right now it strikes that sweet spot between comprehensive coverage and cost. Excluding the Part B deductible, it kicks in to cover 100% of Medicare-approved costs like hospital coinsurance, Part B coinsurance, skilled nursing facility care, and even excess charges that my second-place option, a Plan N, doesn't cover. I've had a lot of people tell me "but I googled it and only 2-3% of doctors bill those excess charges so why wouldn't I just get a Plan N if it's usually cheaper?" and I will say that it's very attractive for many individuals. That's not to just completely trash other options, but the case for the Plan G though is just simply peace of mind, something I know most seniors ask for with their Medigap policies. Individuals that want predictable costs will generally be more satisfied going that route.
Answered by Taylor Langlois on March 12, 2025
Agent Licensed in KS, CO, MO, NE, OK & TX
My recommendation would be Plan "N" for those new to Medicare. It has a much lower monthly premium and it's yearly increases are less that the more popular plan "G".
Answered by William Lewkowski on March 25, 2025
Broker Licensed in TN, AL, AR & 30 other states
In my opinion that would have to be the Medicare supplement PLAN G. With a yearly deductible of $257, the ability to go to any hospital/ provider that accepts Medicare, and no out of pocket costs it works well for most of my supplement clients. The only downside is the yearly increase for the premiums.
Answered by Gregg Matheny on April 6, 2025
Agent Licensed in AZ & UT
Everyone's situation is different. But the "G" Plan for new enrollees, for those who turned 65 after January 1, 2020, is the plan that holds the most benefits. Of course, those "G" plans will be priced higher than the "N" or the High "G" plan. Word of caution that some companies are developing plans they are calling "G" but in a different perspective. These are accepted and treated in a similar fashion to PPOs and HMO's, where there is a Network of Doctors and Specialists. The traditional "G" Plan has no networks.
Answered by Norman Smith on March 26, 2025
Agent Licensed in FL & PA
Plan G is the top of the heap for current enrollments. However, you can save $ by choosing a plan N.
Answered by Michael Pyers on March 26, 2025
Broker Licensed in OH & MI
Medicare plans are standardize. Every plan is identical. The difference is that each company determines their price, It makes sense to go to the lowest price option for coverage.
Answered by Aaron Solomon on March 27, 2025
Broker Licensed in OH, LA & TX
The answer to this question depends on a number of factors, including the senior's age, location, and risk tolerance. These factors are important because some carriers specialize in providing value to seniors who are turning 65, while others tend to focus on seniors who are older. In addition, the competitiveness of a carrier (with regards to monthly premium) often depends on the zip code of the applicant. Finally, some carriers offer a stronger Plan N or innovative Plan G, while others tend to focus on Plan G.
Usually Plan G or High Deductible G — they offer great coverage and predictable costs. But it really depends on your state and how pricing works there, so it's not one-size-fits-all.
Answered by Brian Krantz on March 25, 2025
Broker Licensed in NY, AK, AL & 48 other states
Plan G offers comprehensive coverage, filling many of the "gaps" in Original Medicare (Part A and Part B). Plan G will cover your hospital deductibles, Part B coinsurance, skilled nursing coinsurance and Part B excess charges. Plan G does have a yearly deductible that the government changes the 1st of January each year. This plan has the most extensive coverage for anyone just turning 65.
Answered by Linda Bolan on March 12, 2025
Agent Licensed in IN
Every Senior has different needs, not all plans work for all seniors. The best thing to do would be discuss or have a needs analysis done by a licensed agent.
Answered by Adriane Williams on April 4, 2025
Agent Licensed in OK, AK, AL & 48 other states
Tags:
Coverage
Medicare Supplement
Agents: Share Your Expertise
Have insights or experiences related to this topic? Help others by sharing your knowledge and answering this question.
Add Your Answer
