Why do some people regret choosing a Medicare Advantage plan over Original Medicare?
Answered by 71 licensed agents
The most common regrets:
Network restrictions. Advantage plans limit you to specific doctors and hospitals. If your doctor leaves the network — or you need a specialist — you may be stuck or paying out-of-pocket.
Prior authorizations. Many services require the plan’s approval before you get care. Denials and delays frustrate people who expected seamless coverage.
Out-of-pocket costs add up. Low premiums are appealing, but copays, coinsurance, and the annual MOOP (up to $9,350 in-network in 2025) can surprise people with serious health events.
Travel limitations. Most Advantage plans only cover emergencies outside their service area. Snowbirds and frequent travelers often get caught off guard.
Can’t easily switch back. If you want to return to Original Medicare and add a Medigap plan, you may face medical underwriting in most states — meaning you could be denied or pay much higher premiums based on health conditions.
Answered by John Hawk on June 8, 2026
Broker Licensed in NJ, NY, PA & SC
1. Limited Provider Networks
Medicare Advantage plans often require you to use a network of doctors and hospitals. If your preferred providers aren’t in-network, you might face higher costs or have to switch doctors.
2. Prior Authorization and Referrals
Many Medicare Advantage plans require prior approval for certain tests or specialist visits, which can delay care or add hassle.
3. Variable Coverage and Benefits
Benefits, premiums, and out-of-pocket costs can change every year, which means you might pay more or lose certain coverage unexpectedly.
4. Surprise Costs
Even with $0 premiums, copays, coinsurance, and deductibles can add up—especially for hospital stays or specialty drugs.
5. Travel Limitations
Most Medicare Advantage plans have limited coverage outside your service area, which can be a problem if you travel frequently.
Bottom line:
Medicare Advantage can be a great fit if you want extra benefits and lower premiums—but if you value flexibility, stability, and predictable costs, Original Medicare with a Medigap plan might be a better choice.
Would you like help reviewing your current plan or exploring other options?
Contact us.
Answered by Steven Graves on July 1, 2025
Agent Licensed in TX
But when you get sick and they start arguing with your doctor and denying the treatment plan he/she recommends, that delays care and causes stress. Also, as you use more frequent care, the copays for each service can really add up and become expensive.
Lastly, the limited network of a Medicare Advantage Plan can also be a problem when you need care but the network doctor can’t see you for months or you need a bed in a Skilled Nursing Facility and there are no available beds in the in-network facilities. When you’re extremely sick, you want more options, not to be restricted. Medicare Advantage plans are restrictive by nature, to keep premiums low and to allow them to make a profit.
Answered by Barbara Barnes, CMIP® on June 6, 2025
Agent Licensed in PA
1) Inability to switch back to a Medicare supplement with preexisting conditions (unless a guaranteed issue special enrollment criteria is met)—not a common option for very sick folks. Meaning most sick folks can change from one MAPD to another in the fall AEP, but not back to Original Medicare with a Medicare Supplement in most circumstances (cancer, stroke, COPD, heart attack, nitroglycerin, insulin, dementia, etc.).
2) Large yearly maximum out-of-pocket (MOOP) charges: such as 20% co-pays for chemotherapy, DME, etc. Some PPO plans have a smaller in-network MOOP (i.e., $4,900) and out-of-network MOOP ($10,000).
3) Network restrictions of some HMO plans and large co-pays for out-of-network PPO plans.
Answered by Christopher Boyd RICP, CLTC, LTCP, APP, MAML on August 16, 2025
Agent Licensed in IN, KY, MI, OH, PA & TN
Medigap (Medicare Supplement) policies do not require prior authorization, and policyholders can generally see any provider who accepts Medicare. However, Medigap plans charge a monthly premium that must be paid regardless of whether medical services are used.
There is no one-size-fits-all Medicare plan. Coverage needs and costs vary from person to person.
An independent insurance broker can review an individual’s specific situation, explain available options, and recommend the plan that best fits their healthcare needs and financial goals.
Answered by Rukshini Sandrasegaran on April 27, 2026
Broker Licensed in AZ
When people truly understand MA plans and how they work, most will choose Original Medicare. Those that choose MA at this point—they are prepared, understand the coverage, and usually have no issue with the terms they agreed to. The “regret” comes from a faulty buying process and lack of understanding. People who get sold on “free insurance that covers dental” are likely going to regret that decision if their health declines and they need more support.
Insurance is very personal and very confusing. Request physical materials about any plan you’re interested in—namely the SOB (summary of benefits). Ask all the questions all the time; they are never “dumb” questions, but they can save you a lot of money in retirement.
Answered by Brittany Stickney on November 26, 2025
Broker Licensed in NE, AZ, CO & 10 other states
Common reasons people regret it:
Network restrictions
Their doctor or hospital isn’t in-network
Referrals & prior authorizations
Delays or extra steps to get care approved
Higher costs when sick
Copays add up quickly with frequent care
Limited flexibility
Harder to see specialists or get care while traveling
Why this happens:
Many people choose based on $0 premiums and extra benefits, without fully understanding how the plan works when they’re not healthy.
Bottom line:
Medicare Advantage can work great—but it’s important to choose it for the right reasons, not just the upfront savings.
Answered by Lauren Fodde on March 30, 2026
Broker Licensed in MO & FL
And if you want to leave Medicare Advantage and change to traditional Medicare with a Medicare Supplement (Medigap), you may be denied because of a pre-existing condition.
Answered by William Lewkowski on April 10, 2025
Broker Licensed in TN, AL, AR & 30 other states
On Original Medicare, there usually are no pre-authorizations required. If it's covered by Medicare, then if you have a supplement, your supplement will cover the coinsurance. However, that is changing for 2026. There will be a pilot program in several states requiring pre-authorizations even with Original Medicare.
Answered by Fewee Bondad on November 17, 2025
Broker Licensed in LA, AZ, NC, OK, SC & TX
The con is using a network, but I don’t really say this is a bad thing, as most networks in the major cities have a robust network of doctors and specialists.
Original Medicare, in my opinion, has a big con, which is Original Medicare only covers 80%, which leaves you open to a 20% bill every time. If you have a year where you’ve been sick and have had to visit the doctor multiple times or have a hospital stay, that can hit you hard financially. There is no annual or lifetime cap with Original Medicare (Part A & Part B).
Hope this gives some insight.
Be well!
Answered by Toni Chavez on June 8, 2025
Broker Licensed in AZ, CA, NM, NV & UT
A Medicare Supplement covers more medical costs as compared to an advantage, though for an additional premium. These are risks that an Advantage plan member needs to take into consideration, going into an advantage plan with their eyes wide open, knowing that no one has a crystal ball to predict the future.
Answered by Dorothy Lam on April 16, 2025
Agent Licensed in IL, IA & IN
Original Medicare is only Part A and Part B. You would be required to purchase a Part D drug plan to avoid penalties. Original Medicare does not cover everything, and "generally" only 80% of your medical costs. Med Advantage and Supplements can help address these shortfalls and save you a significant amount of money either way.
However, there are distinct differences between Advantage and Supplement Plans. A lot of regrets come from not understanding these tradeoffs at the beginning is what I hear the most.
You need to really understand how you manage your health care. I see the need for each of these depending on the individual. Cost is a big part of this decision, and be sure you understand the plan and how it works. Nobody likes surprises, especially with healthcare.
If you start with a Supplement plan and want to try the Medicare Advantage plan, you do have 12 months to "try it out." If you find that the plan does not work for you, you can switch back to the same plan (Supplement plan) you had before without medical underwriting. You can only do this ONE TIME, so be aware of this when deciding.
If you want to go back to Original Medicare, you do have opportunities to do so as well.
Answered by Betty Dean on October 13, 2025
Broker Licensed in GA, AZ, IA & 6 other states
By contrast, Medicare Advantage plans involve a few extra steps. First, they operate within a network, so it’s important to make sure your doctors and hospitals participate in your specific plan. Second, these plans often follow a “pay as you go” structure, meaning you may need to meet certain copays, coinsurance, or a deductible before the plan pays the remaining costs. Additionally, if you need to see a specialist, you’ll often need a referral or prior approval from your primary care doctor.
With Original Medicare, you have the freedom to see any doctor or specialist who accepts Medicare, without needing referrals or worrying about network restrictions.
These are just a few of the main differences to keep in mind when choosing between the two options.
Answered by Gus Karigan on November 4, 2025
Broker Licensed in IL, GA & MI
2) Sometimes people do not fully understand how their Medicare Advantage plan works prior to joining.
3) Sometimes people do not realize that this is managed care and sometimes takes longer for procedures to be approved by the plan.
4) This is sometimes due to the agent doing a poor job in explaining how these plans work.
5) Currently 54% of the Medicare-eligible population are using Medicare Advantage plans.
6) Since these plans involve lower or no monthly payments for membership, members are surprised/disappointed when confronted with a co-pay for the procedure. Instead of paying a monthly premium for benefits one seldom uses, one IS responsible for a share of cost for some benefits.
Answered by Thomas Magnus, RHU on August 18, 2025
Broker Licensed in CA, AZ, NV, OR & WA
I always say, if they ended up going into the hospital and incurring large health bills, they would be much happier most likely with Original Medicare and a Supplement, but if they never went into a hospital and never incurred huge bills - they would have been far better off with an MAPD plan.
So to me, their regret stems from being improperly informed and/or maybe not really understanding what they were told. I find the latter is often the reason. We agents must provide a lot of information - information that took us years to understand thoroughly, and our clients expect to understand it in less than an hour.
Answered by Lowana Richardson on July 20, 2026
Agent Licensed in HI, AZ & CA
Answered by Mark Boone on January 14, 2026
Agent Licensed in MN, FL, MI & NC, OH, SC & VA
Doctors may change from year to year as to whether they will accept a certain plan or not, and then the patient with the MA / MAPD plan will have to look for another doctor.
You must also remember that the 20% of Original Medicare has no ceiling, which can also be costly for someone with a lot of medical issues.
Answered by Jeffrey Jon on June 24, 2025
Agent Licensed in TX
Answered by Anthony Castelluccio on April 3, 2025
Agent Licensed in PA, DE, MD, NJ & VA
Another important difference is with Original Medicare, as long as your doctor(s) take Medicare, you are covered—with a Medicare Advantage Plan, you'll be working with a PPO or HMO type organization, and you NEED to make sure YOUR doctors are part of that plan!
Medicare Advantage plans change year to year too! We have several situations this year where doctors who were prior a part of the network are NO longer in the network!
Work with someone who can go over all the Medicare "alphabet soup" and who can offer both: Medicare Supplement/Medigap AND Medicare Advantage and can give you the pros and cons of both, so YOU can make smart decisions!
Answered by Tony Capraro III on April 7, 2025
Agent Licensed in NH & ME
So that can be problematic in some cases and make them wish they had chosen a Med Supp plan. Both types of plans have their advantages and disadvantages, and it is important to understand the differences between both before making your own healthcare decision.
Answered by Marsha Reiniers on April 7, 2025
Agent Licensed in FL, GA, MI & NC, PA, SC & VA
Limited provider network, higher out-of-pocket costs, referrals and authorizations, plan changes year to year, traveling in and out of state.
Because these issues often only become apparent after someone enrolls, many people don’t realize the limitations until they need care that isn’t covered or are faced with high out-of-pocket costs. It's essential to compare all your options carefully to ensure the plan you choose aligns with your health needs and preferences.
Answered by Calvin Fritz on April 8, 2025
Broker Licensed in MO, AL, AR & 22 other states
Answered by Susan Winters on July 16, 2025
Agent Licensed in FL, AL, AR & 16 other states
Original Medicare generally offers broader provider access, while Medicare Advantage may offer additional benefits and lower upfront costs but typically has network and plan-specific rules.
Bottom line: The “most suitable” option depends on the person’s doctors, prescriptions, health needs, budget, and preferred hospitals.
Answered by Lakita Bradley on August 3, 2026
Broker Licensed in FL, AL, AR & 29 other states
First of all, you have to understand when someone goes on a Medicare Advantage plan, they have what they call a trial rights period, which is 12 months. They can test it out. If within those 12 months they don't like it, they can revert back. In most cases, they can revert back and go to Original Medicare with their supplement.
One of the biggest regrets, I think, is when someone gets on Medicare Advantage and then later on they want to go to a supplement plan with the prescription drug plan, but they have to go through medical underwriting to be able to do that.
The medical underwriting is not super strict, but they typically ask you questions like, have you been in the hospital in the last many days? They ask you if you have specific medical conditions. They're pretty serious. I mean, it's not, they call it an abbreviated underwriting, but more times than not, people can get through that underwriting, and they'll be able to get a Medicare supplement plan and move away from Advantage.
Answered by Steve and Sue Brauer on August 30, 2025
Broker Licensed in AZ & CA
Answered by Tim Measures on August 18, 2025
Agent Licensed in CA
With a supplement/Medigap, you're covered for the remaining 20% on covered health services and supplies. You do pay a monthly premium for the supplement/Medigap plan, as it does provide consistency and flexibility.
With an Advantage plan, you pay as you go and are subject to changes every year in coverage and out-of-pocket expenses. There are plans that cover specific conditions at a relatively low cost that can help mitigate big bills.
Answered by Edward Wooten on August 13, 2025
Broker Licensed in IL & MO
There are many clients in the past couple of years who have moved from Original Medicare with a Medigap plan over to Medicare Advantage based on the cost of the Medigap plan rising recently. Then, when they get their co-pay for a procedure, the "pain" of the Medigap plan premium is forgotten because of the unfamiliar bill that arrives in the mail. There is also the fact that with Medicare Advantage, there is an opportunity for changes in networks, etc.
It is best to spend time with a Medicare broker who will provide you information on all plans - even better, documentation on your conversations on what decisions led to your choice. It is nice to be reminded why you chose the plan that you did.
Answered by Adam Ashby on July 20, 2026
Broker Licensed in CO, GA, IL & 6 other states
So, your question should read: Since the Advantage plan is Part C/D, the inquiry should say: What are the differences between Parts A, B, C and D?
Unfortunately, due to the current administration's edicts about healthcare, since a Medicare Advantage is subsidized BY the Federal Govt., the benefits of these "MA" plans can change at the drop of a hat, I'm afraid.
In addition, the expression known as "Prior Authorization" has proven to be highly controversial. Here's how: there are times when a doctor forgets to get your insurance firm's approval for a simple procedure or even a prescription drug. In the latter case, there's what's known as "step therapy," where a patient will be forced to use a different and cheaper drug for your condition than the one initially prescribed. Weeks can go by where you are not using the best possible drug for your condition!
Moreover, if a treatment has also NOT been submitted to your Advantage plan's company in advance, that can also be delayed for a while, too.
So, if you can afford a monthly Med. Supplement premium, that will always be your best bet.
Answered by Steven Bleicher on July 13, 2025
Broker Licensed in AZ
People choose Medicare Advantage because of the low cost upfront. Medicare Advantage includes additional benefits, like a drug plan, some limited dental, vision and hearing. And the cost is zero dollars without a dental upgrade.
This may look enticing, and when you add a hospital indemnity to cover the out-of-pocket expenses for being hospitalized, it’s not a horrible plan. When compared to having a supplement, there are no surprise charges.
If you go with Original Medicare, you will have to buy your own dental, vision, hearing, and the cost for a drug plan on top of the cost of the Medigap.
If you have additional questions, you can always reach out to a broker like me.
Contact me.
Answered by Harold Randolph on June 28, 2025
Broker Licensed in MI, IN, KY & OH
Answered by James Stang on July 7, 2025
Agent Licensed in OH, FL & KY
With Medicare Advantage, network problems and medication/doctor changes might require a plan change, which may result in different levels of benefits and costs. It's usually a "package" deal; to fix one thing, you might break another, which is not common but definitely can be difficult to deal with as a consumer. To me, it's fun helping people figure things out!
Answered by Josh Vojtush on April 28, 2025
Broker Licensed in OH, FL, IL & MI, NC, SC & VA
But you have NO CHOICE OF DOCTORS, No COVERAGE when you travel, as you are OUT OF NETWORK, and cannot see the specialist facilities such as Moffitt, Mayo, and the Cleveland Clinic. You give complete control of your health to a group of individuals to decide IF you can see someone and cover you.
Answered by Norman Smith on April 19, 2025
Agent Licensed in FL, AL, NJ & PA
Medicare Advantage plans also usually have referral and prior authorizations required for specialist visits or other services.
Answered by Ricardo Lourenço on October 25, 2025
Agent Licensed in FL, CA, MI & NC, OH, PA & TX
Answered by DeeDee Whitlock on October 20, 2025
Broker Licensed in LA
Answered by Justin Kramer on October 2, 2025
Broker Licensed in IA
All of these questions need to be addressed before anyone enrolls into a Medicare Advantage plan, so there is no regret afterwards.
Answered by Don Hansford on October 24, 2025
Broker Licensed in TX
Answered by Erica Huffstetler on October 14, 2025
Broker Licensed in AZ, FL, OH, SC & TX
I don’t see much regret for advantage plans. I’m on one myself and I’m very happy with it. There is no perfect plan, so what do people not like? Sometimes their doctor is maybe not on the plan, some approvals are needed, but that’s the same under group insurance plans.
The thing I don’t like myself is that Part B drugs you pay 20%. This is expensive, and in that year, you would hit your maximum out-of-pocket. But good plans? Yes.
Answered by Lt Col Tim Brown on April 11, 2025
Broker Licensed in TN, AL, CO & 10 other states
Neither Original Medicare (with a Supplemental plan) nor an Advantage Care plans are perfect. Both have upside AND downsides. The critical factors are understanding how the plan works and choosing one that fits your individual needs.
Answered by Don Golding on February 17, 2026
Broker Licensed in TX, AL, AR & 5 other states
Answered by Michael Pyers on May 2, 2025
Broker Licensed in OH & MI
Answered by Maci Mishler on June 9, 2025
Broker Licensed in NE, AR, KS & MO, ND, OK & TX
Answered by Stacey Gaines on October 30, 2025
Agent Licensed in MS, LA, TN & TX
There is no perfect answer when it comes to choosing a Medicare plan because everyone is different and has varying health needs. Advantage plans can be a great option, but they are not for everyone, and not every plan is created equally. If this is an option you are considering, then I would recommend sitting down with an experienced individual to discuss if it is the right option for you.
Answered by Paul Wyatt on August 20, 2025
Broker Licensed in TN, KY & MS
Doctors and hospitals dropping out of network or being dropped from the network.
Prior authorizations, prior approval
Referrals
Answered by Mary Turner on April 1, 2026
Broker Licensed in FL
Answered by Adam Ernst on December 29, 2025
Agent Licensed in NC, SC & TN
Answered by Heather Johnson on August 28, 2025
Broker Licensed in MO, IA, KS & NE
Answered by Meghan Blankenship on November 15, 2025
Broker Licensed in FL, MD & OH
Answered by Todd Bostic on July 8, 2025
Broker Licensed in TX, AL, AZ & 12 other states
Having only A & B without a supplement or Advantage plan can leave a person responsible for a large out-of-pocket if they have a costly medical event.
Supplements are best; however, a Medicare Advantage plan is appealing, as lots of plans have zero monthly premiums and include Part D drugs, eliminating the need to purchase a standalone Part D plan. Reach out if you need more assistance.
Answered by Maureen Gildea on April 6, 2026
Broker Licensed in ME, FL & MA
Answered by Terri Reagin on July 7, 2025
Broker Licensed in OK, AR, CO & 6 other states
Answered by Michael Denniston on June 22, 2025
Agent Licensed in FL, AL, AR & 11 other states
Being familiar with what your needs are, and reviewing the plans' details through comparisons becomes vital in helping one to make the best decision for one's self, at that time. Remember, plans may change offered services from year to year.
Answered by Dianna Muhammad on October 18, 2025
Agent Licensed in IL, CA, FL & 8 other states
Answered by Holly Douglas on October 6, 2025
Broker Licensed in TN & KY
Answered by Jill Belvin on November 30, 2025
Agent Licensed in TX, AZ, FL, MI & NJ
Answered by Ray McCauley on May 4, 2026
Broker Licensed in CA, AZ, FL & ID, NV, SC & TN
Answered by Valentina Gatewood on June 16, 2025
Broker Licensed in CA, AZ, ID & NJ
Answered by Angel Cayocca on November 10, 2026
Agent Licensed in MO, AL, AR & 5 other states
Answered by Kristen Skinner on November 3, 2025
Broker Licensed in OK
Answered by Glenn Alterman on May 19, 2025
Broker Licensed in TX, AZ, CA & FL, NJ, OH & TN
Answered by Nick Sarant on December 1, 2025
Agent Licensed in SC
Answered by Carol Conner on December 19, 2025
Broker Licensed in TX
Answered by Jack Mayer on September 29, 2025
Agent Licensed in CA & NV
Answered by Roseann Vandevender on March 16, 2026
Agent Licensed in OH, AZ, CO & TX
Answered by Pauline Weiland on April 13, 2026
Agent Licensed in AZ, CA, MS, NV & TX
Medicare Advantage may cost you a monthly of zero, which is not what Social Security takes for your Medicare Part B, is for the plan, but it may have certain cost share and copayments.
It also has many extra benefits.
Make sure you work with an agent that will check all your needs.
Answered by Rodolfo Rojas on June 26, 2025
Broker Licensed in NV, AL, AR & 36 other states
Answered by Adam Paul on November 16, 2026
Broker Licensed in CA, NV, OK & OR
Answered by Donna Berube on March 31, 2026
Agent Licensed in NH
Answered by Mark Mullinax on December 29, 2025
Agent Licensed in GA, AL, FL & NC, SC, TN & TX
Answered by Andrew Zurbuch, MBA on July 30, 2025
Broker Licensed in IN, FL, KY, MO, OH & TN
Answered by Mike Henry on May 3, 2025
Agent Licensed in TX
Answered by Bubi Gorgevich on October 1, 2025
Broker Licensed in SC, AZ, CA & 7 other states
Tags: Medicare Advantage
Agents: Share Your Expertise
Have insights or experiences related to this topic? Help others by sharing your knowledge and answering this question.
Seniors: Ask a Question of Your Own
Questions are generally answered within 1 to 3 business days. Receive valuable perspectives from multiple licensed agents and brokers.
Ask a Question





































































