I’m 68 with Medicare and a HealthSpring supplement, and my new employer offers company-paid insurance. Can I keep all three to cover gaps or doctors outside one plan’s network?

Answered by 10 licensed agents

Yes, you can generally keep Medicare, your HealthSpring Medicare Supplement, and your new employer's health insurance at the same time. However, having three policies doesn't necessarily mean all three will pay your medical bills.

The first thing I would want to know is how many employees your new company has. This makes a big difference in how your coverage works.

If your employer has 20 or more employees, the employer's group health plan generally pays first, and Medicare pays second. If the company has fewer than 20 employees, Medicare generally pays first, followed by your employer's insurance. There are some exceptions, particularly with multi-employer plans.

Your HealthSpring Medicare Supplement works with Original Medicare to help cover certain deductibles, copays, and coinsurance. It doesn't automatically pay whatever your employer's insurance leaves behind, and it doesn't provide additional coverage for services Medicare doesn't cover.

Now, here's something worth considering. If you're paying monthly premiums for your HealthSpring Supplement while your employer is providing insurance at no cost, you could potentially be paying for overlapping coverage you don't need.

Before making any changes, I would strongly recommend having an independent Medicare broker review all three policies. They can help determine which insurance pays first, whether your doctors are covered, and whether keeping all three makes financial sense.

One important warning: Don't cancel your Medicare Supplement until you've reviewed your options. Depending on your state and circumstances, you might have to pass medical underwriting to get that coverage back later.

My goal would be to make sure you're getting the most out of your employer's benefits without paying for unnecessary coverage or giving up valuable Medicare protections.

Answered by Jon Cavanaugh on October 12, 2026

Broker Licensed in NV

Answered by Jon Cavanaugh Medicare Insurance Agent
Yes, you can keep all three. But having more coverage doesn’t always mean you get more benefits, and you may end up paying for coverage that overlaps.

Who pays first depends on your employer’s size:

20 or more employees: Your job’s plan pays first, then Medicare.

Fewer than 20 employees: Medicare pays first, then your job’s plan.

What about doctors?

Medicare and your Supplement work with any doctor who accepts Medicare. No network.

Your job’s plan may have a network. Outside that network, Medicare and your Supplement can still cover you.

Things to consider:

Your Supplement only pays after Medicare, so some of its coverage may overlap with your job’s plan.

Be careful about dropping your Supplement. At 68, you may have to answer health questions to get it back later, and you could be turned down.

Ask your employer’s benefits office how its plan works with Medicare.

Note: Supplement rules vary by state. Some states make it easier to get a Supplement back later.

Not sure which coverage to keep? Contact me and I’ll help you compare costs so you’re not paying for coverage you don’t need.

Answered by Yulonda Clark on October 12, 2026

Agent Licensed in IL, AZ, GA, IN & TX

Answered by Yulonda Clark Medicare Insurance Agent
To begin with, HealthSpring is a Medigap plan. Both Medicare, itself, and Medigap plans have no networks, per se. You can visit any provider who accepts Medicare.

That said, you should begin by examining whether, or to what extent, your providers lie outside of the network for your company plan. If that is minimal, then it may not be worth continuing to pay both Part B and Medigap premiums - which could easily exceed any higher copays you might encounter.

However, the other issue - which I would need to research further - is whether you can have coverage by the group plan, Medicare and Medigap. You can have Medicare as the secondary payer behind your group plan, but that may be all.

Answered by Rick Bechtel on October 5, 2026

Broker Licensed in WA

Answered by Rick Bechtel Medicare Insurance Agent
Yes. If your employer has 20 or more employees, their plan will be primary and Medicare and the supplement will be secondary. If it's a smaller company, your Medicare and supplement plans will be primary.

Answered by Marcia West on October 13, 2026

Agent Licensed in WA, FL, GA, MI, TX & VA

Answered by Marcia West Medicare Insurance Agent
You can keep them all but why would you? The employer coverage becomes the primary insurance and Medicare becomes secondary. It would be a challenge to coordinate 3 plans.

If the employer pays 100% and your out of pocket deductible and maximum out of pocket makes sense cancel Part B Medicare and the supplemental. If the employer insurance would have a higher out of pocket cost I would probably keep my Medicare plans.

Answered by David Ion on November 9, 2026

Broker Licensed in CA, AZ, ID & 6 other states

Answered by David Ion Medicare Insurance Agent
Yes — potentially, but I would not recommend assuming that all three will coordinate simply because you have them. The key is determining exactly what your “HealthSpring supplement” is and how the new employer plan coordinates with Medicare.

If by HealthSpring supplement you mean a Medicare Supplement (Medigap) policy, you can generally have Original Medicare + a Medigap policy + employer group health coverage. However, the employer plan and Medicare have specific rules about who pays first, and the Medigap policy is designed to supplement Original Medicare, not to act as a general secondary network insurance plan.

Answered by Gary Foucha on October 5, 2026

Agent Licensed in LA, GA, MS & TX

Answered by Gary Foucha Medicare Insurance Agent
Yes, you can, provided you are enrolled in Medicare Parts A & B; however, it’s not necessary simply to be able to choose a doctor you like, and it could end up costing you thousands in unnecessary costs. I recommend that you meet with your Medicare agent or give me a call, as the best option will be to do a review of your current group coverage and network, compare it to what you would pay on a Medicare Supplement with a Part D, and choose the best option.

Supplements have no network, and the Plan G offers platinum level coverage, so you could pick your doctor and drop your current group plan, as long as it makes sense financially. I would love to walk you through all your options.

Answered by Susan Thomas on October 5, 2026

Agent Licensed in MT, CA, FL & 6 other states

Answered by Susan Thomas Medicare Insurance Agent
If you keep all three, your claims will be quite confusing. Depending on the size of the company, either Medicare or company insurance will be primary. You would have to cancel your supplement.

Answered by Armand Smith on October 6, 2026

Broker Licensed in AZ, CA, CO & 8 other states

Answered by Armand Smith Medicare Insurance Agent
Yes, you can keep all three. Your employer plan will be the primary insurance, and Medicare and your supplement being your secondary.

Answered by Garoll Parks on October 16, 2026

Agent Licensed in CA, AZ, NV, OR, TX & WA

Answered by Garoll Parks Medicare Insurance Agent
I would not duplicate insurances because you will be paying for both, but only one will be paying claims. Call Social Security and ask about maybe putting your Part B on hold and cancelling your supplement if you think it is a better deal with the new employer. I would not want to see you paying for both. Pick one or the other.

Answered by Ed Hollum on October 12, 2026

Agent Licensed in NH, MA & ME

Answered by Ed Hollum Medicare Insurance Agent

Tags: Advice for Seniors Coverage Medicare Advantage

Agents: Share Your Expertise

Have insights or experiences related to this topic? Help others by sharing your knowledge and answering this question.

Seniors: Ask a Question of Your Own

Questions are generally answered within 1 to 3 business days. Receive valuable perspectives from multiple licensed agents and brokers.

Ask a Question