Medicare Advantage by State: Which States Have 5-Star Plans and the Highest Enrollment

Medicare Advantage by State: Which States Have 5-Star Plans and the Highest Enrollment
  • Last Updated October 16, 2026


Reviewed by Sebastian Michaud Medicare Insurance Agent

Reviewed by Sebastian Michaud

Medicare Broker Licensed in AL, AK, AR & 43 other states


Medicare Advantage (MA) plans combine Parts A, B, and usually Part D, with added benefits. Enrollment, plan variety, and star ratings all shift significantly by state, so where you live shapes what you can actually buy. With ongoing changes heading into 2026, understanding where these plans perform best matters more than ever. These plans thrive unevenly across states due to local competition, provider networks, and consumer adoption. Based on CMS contract and enrollment data and KFF's 2026 Medicare Advantage enrollment update, here are the top five states for enrollment, plan quality, and variety, plus which states have 5-star Medicare Advantage plans available.

Data current as of August 2026. Enrollment figures come from CMS Medicare Advantage contract and enrollment files and KFF's 2026 Medicare Advantage enrollment update, both accessed August 2026. Star ratings, plan availability, and carrier participation are reset by CMS every fall, so these numbers move year to year. Treat them as a snapshot of where the market stands today, not a permanent ranking, and review your own options during each Annual Enrollment Period.

What Makes a State the Best for Medicare Advantage?

We use the following criteria:

  • Enrollment rate: the percentage of Medicare beneficiaries in a state who are enrolled in MA.

  • Plan quality: CMS star ratings and percentage of enrollees in 4+ star plans.

  • Plan variety: number of carriers and plan options available in counties. Variety matters because more competing plans means a better chance one of them actually matches your doctors, your prescriptions, and your budget — and more room to switch if your plan changes.

  • Supplemental benefits: availability of dental, vision, hearing, OTC, etc.

These metrics reveal which states offer the best mix of access, value, and choice.

Medicare Advantage Enrollment by State: The Top 5

1. Florida

Florida leads MA enrollment with over 60% of Medicare beneficiaries enrolled. It combines high saturation with competitive carriers offering robust supplemental benefits. Humana, UnitedHealthcare, Aetna, and Blue Cross dominate, giving retirees a wide range of plan types and networks.

Map of the United States highlighting Florida, Michigan, Pennsylvania, Connecticut, and Rhode Island as Medicare Advantage hotspots.

Five standout states for Medicare Advantage in 2026: Florida, Michigan, Pennsylvania, Connecticut, and Rhode Island.

2. Michigan

Michigan is among seven states (AL, CT, MI, HI, ME, FL, RI) with 60%+ MA penetration. Rapid enrollment gains occurred in Wayne, Oakland, and Kent counties during 2024–25, driven by competitive plan offerings and provider partnerships. Multiple local and national carriers ensure strong plan variety.

3. Pennsylvania

Also in the 60%+ cohort. Enrollment spiked in Allegheny and Philadelphia Counties thanks to heavy enrollment during last year’s Annual Enrollment Period. Large counties also have 10+ plan options monthly in many areas, indicating high variety.

4. Connecticut

Though smaller in population, Connecticut has over 60% MA penetration. Its compact geography supports strong carrier competition and high access to 4+ star plans. Quality isn't uniform, though: beneficiaries in rural counties tend to find fewer 4- and 5-star plan options than those in urban centers like Hartford.

5. Rhode Island

Also in the 60%+ MA penetration group. Rhode Island benefits from dense provider access and urban markets. Star quality remains consistently high, placing many beneficiaries in 4+ star plans. Its small size brings uniform access across the state.

Comparison at a Glance

State MA Enrollment 4+ Star Access Plan Variety per County
Florida

60%+

High (multiple carriers)

10+ in most metro counties

Michigan

60%+

Strong in metro areas

High in Wayne, Oakland, Kent

Pennsylvania

60%+

Strong in urban hubs

10+ options in many counties

Connecticut

60%+

High access statewide

Good variety, some low-tier spots

Rhode Island

60%+

High across state

Consistently good options

What Medicare Agents Say: Do MA Plans Really Save Money?

Leslie Kaz

Syndicated Insurance Agency LLC • Sherman Oaks, CA

Do Medicare Advantage plans really save seniors money in the long run? Why or why not?

Short answer: Sometimes yes. Sometimes no. It depends on the person — not the TV commercial.

Here’s the real deal:

Medicare Advantage plans can save seniors money when they’re matched correctly to how someone actually uses healthcare.

Why they can save money:

Lower (sometimes $0) monthly premiums

Built-in extras like dental, vision, hearing, fitness

Annual out-of-pocket maximums (Original Medicare doesn’t have one)

Why they don’t always save money:

Provider networks can be limited

Costs add up if you go out-of-network

Heavy users of care may hit the max and pay more than expected

Benefits change every year

Here’s the part commercials skip:

The plan isn’t the problem — the fit is.

That’s why working with my office matters. We offer concierge service, meaning we don’t just enroll you and disappear. If you’re confused, can’t find a provider, or something isn’t working the way you expected, we step in and help fix it.

Bottom line:

Medicare Advantage can absolutely save money — when chosen strategically and supported properly. One-size-fits-all plans usually cost more in the long run.

What These States Have in Common

They share these traits:

  • High MA adoption (60%+)

  • Competitive insurance markets with multiple major and regional carriers

  • Diverse plan selections, often 10+ options per metro area

  • Strong access to 4+ star plans, driven by quality measures

States With the Fewest Medicare Advantage Plan Options

The bottom of the enrollment table looks nothing like the top. Alaska sits at the very low end, with almost no Medicare Advantage presence at all, which is why Original Medicare paired with a supplement is the default there. Montana and Wyoming also run well under 40% enrollment with thin plan choice.

Low enrollment mostly comes down to geography. Medicare Advantage runs on negotiated provider networks, and building one is hard in a state where the nearest hospital is two hours away. Fewer networks produce fewer plans, and fewer plans mean less pressure on carriers to compete on benefits. Rural counties inside the high-enrollment states do better, since they can usually tap a network built around a nearby metro.

Which Companies Sell the Most Medicare Advantage Plans?

Asking which Medicare Advantage plans are the largest is really a question about carrier market share. A handful of companies cover most of the national market, and the pecking order has barely moved in years:

  • UnitedHealthcare is the largest Medicare Advantage carrier in the country by enrollment.
  • Humana is second. Between them, the two cover close to half of everyone in Medicare Advantage.
  • CVS Health / Aetna is third.
  • Blue Cross Blue Shield affiliates, Kaiser Permanente, Centene, and Cigna account for most of what is left, with the regional Blues plans punching above their national weight inside individual states.

State-level market share looks very different from that national list. Kaiser Permanente is a fraction of UnitedHealthcare's national size, yet it dominates parts of California and holds some of the highest star ratings in the program. Provider-owned and regional carriers routinely outsell the national giants on their home turf.

Size only tells you how many people a carrier covers nationally. A carrier with millions of members may still field a thin network where you live, while a local plan you have never heard of has your cardiologist and your pharmacy in network.

Where 5-Star Medicare Advantage Plans Are Most Available by State

Enrollment share and star ratings don't always track together. A state can have huge MA membership without offering many 5-star contracts, and vice versa. CMS awards 5 stars to only a handful of contracts each year, and their footprints cluster in specific states.

How CMS Decides a Plan's Star Rating

Stars are not a marketing label. CMS scores every Medicare Advantage contract once a year on roughly 40 separate measures and rolls them into a single 1-to-5 rating. Those measures fall into a few buckets:

  • Staying healthy — whether members get recommended screenings, vaccines, and annual check-ups.
  • Managing chronic conditions — how well the plan keeps diabetes, blood pressure, and similar conditions under control.
  • Member experience — survey results on getting appointments, getting care quickly, and overall satisfaction with the plan.
  • Complaints and members leaving — how many people file complaints or drop the plan mid-year.
  • Customer service — how the plan handles calls, appeals, and coverage decisions.

Plans that include drug coverage are also graded on prescription pricing accuracy and medication safety. CMS publishes the underlying scores in its Part C and D performance data each fall. Because member experience and chronic-care control carry real weight, a high rating tells you something useful about how the plan behaves once you are a member — not just what it looks like on a benefits flyer.

That also explains why 5-star contracts keep showing up in the same places. The carriers that earn them tend to be integrated or provider-owned plans — organizations that run both the insurance side and the clinics and hospitals delivering care. Controlling both ends makes it easier to close care gaps, book appointments quickly, and keep members from leaving, which is exactly what the star measures reward. Those systems happen to be concentrated in a handful of states, so the 5-star map looks more like a map of integrated health systems than a map of where the most Medicare beneficiaries live.

For the 2026 plan year, states that consistently show up with 5-star Medicare Advantage plan availability include:

  • California, Wisconsin, and Massachusetts — Kaiser Permanente's 5-star contracts serve members in these markets.

  • Pennsylvania and Ohio — regional Blues and integrated health-system plans have earned 5-star ratings in recent cycles.

  • Minnesota — long-standing 5-star performance from local carriers like HealthPartners and UCare.

  • Florida — a few 5-star contracts operate in select counties, though most Florida plans sit at 4 or 4.5 stars.

Cody Biggs

A Acadian Assurance • Baton Rouge, LA

Which states have 5-star Medicare Advantage plans available?

For 2026, 5-star Medicare Advantage plans are available in 19 states plus Puerto Rico, although availability is county-specific.

Based on the current 2026 plan data, the states include:

California, Colorado, Florida, Georgia, Illinois, Iowa, Kansas, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Missouri, Nevada, New Jersey, New York, North Carolina, Pennsylvania, South Carolina, Texas, and Virginia — plus Puerto Rico.

Having a 5-star contract somewhere in a state doesn’t mean every beneficiary in that state has access to it. It has to be offered in the beneficiary’s county/service area. If it is, the 5-Star SEP can generally be used once between December 8 and November 30 to move into that 5-star plan.

If a 5-star plan is available in your area, you can switch into it once per year outside the normal enrollment windows using the 5-Star Special Enrollment Period. CMS resets star ratings every fall, so the 2027 list won’t match the one above. Check the current Medicare Plan Finder during the Annual Enrollment Period to confirm which contracts hold 5 stars in your ZIP code.

How to Judge Provider Networks by State

Star ratings and plan counts both skip the question that decides most of this: whether your doctors are in the network. A state can look excellent on paper and still be a poor fit if the 5-star plan there excludes the health system you already use.

Network strength tends to follow the same big health systems that earn the high star ratings, which means the deepest Medicare Advantage networks sit around major metro health systems. The trade-off is tighter geography. HMO plans in dense markets like Philadelphia or Hartford often carry deep specialist rosters inside the service area and very little coverage outside it.

If you are managing a condition that needs ongoing specialist care, cardiology and oncology included, check the network before you check the star rating. Look up each specific doctor and hospital in the plan's directory, confirm the referral rules, and ask what happens if your specialist drops out mid-year. Switching out of a plan later is harder than switching in.

Medicare Advantage Plans by State for 2027: What Changes

Everything above describes the 2026 plan year. The 2027 plans are the ones you can actually buy right now, during the Annual Enrollment Period that runs October 15 through December 7, 2026, and there is plenty worth reviewing before 2027 coverage starts.

Three things reset for 2027, and every one of them is state-specific:

  • Star ratings. CMS re-scores every contract each fall. A plan holding 5 stars for 2026 can slip to 4.5 for 2027, and new 5-star contracts turn up in new states. The list above will move.
  • Plan counts and service areas. Carriers add and drop counties annually. Some states gain options for 2027 while others lose them, and a carrier exiting your county is the most common reason people get forced into a switch.
  • Benefits and costs. Supplemental benefits, drug coverage, and out-of-pocket maximums are refiled every year. Read your plan's Annual Notice of Change before assuming next year resembles this one.

So treat any "best Medicare Advantage plans by state for 2027" ranking with suspicion, the snapshot above included. The plan menu gets drawn county by county. Pull up the Medicare Plan Finder for your own ZIP, filter to 4 stars and up, and confirm your doctors are in network before you sign anything.

What This Means for You

Even if you don’t live in one of these top five states, strong Medicare Advantage plans may still be available in your area. Four things to check in your own county:

  • Carrier count and enrollment rate: the number of carriers operating in your county often reflects how competitive the plans are.

  • Star ratings: focus on plans rated 4 stars or higher for better quality and satisfaction.

  • Plan variety: ideally your area should offer five to ten choices, which gives you room to switch without leaving your doctors.

  • Supplemental benefits: review these carefully if you have specific needs such as dental coverage, vision care, or support for chronic conditions. Read the actual limits before you decide, because the extras advertised as "free" often come with annual caps that run out fast.

Use the Medicare Plan Finder on Medicare.gov, or consult a local broker or state insurance advisor for personalized guidance.

Agent Perspective: Original Medicare vs. Medicare Advantage

Emmond Wills

Wills Financial & Benefits LLC. • Nashville, TN

Is Original Medicare or Medicare Advantage better? Why do you recommend one over the other?

The truth is, well neither is “better” for everyone — it depends on the person’s health, doctors, budget, and lifestyle and needs.

What the Numbers Show

The five hotspot states lead MA in enrollment, quality, and choice, but strong plans exist well beyond them. Focus on star ratings, provider access, and benefits in your ZIP code. With careful evaluation and the right Medicare broker near you, you can find an ideal MA plan, no matter where you live.

Find the right plan in your state

Plan counts and star ratings change every year, even in hotspot states. A licensed agent near you can compare every plan available in your ZIP code against your doctors, your prescriptions, and your budget.

Connect with a local Medicare agent

We are not connected with or endorsed by the United States government or the federal Medicare program. Agents listed on this site may not offer every plan available in your area. To review all of your options, visit Medicare.gov, call 1-800-MEDICARE (TTY 1-877-486-2048), or contact your State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP).