I live abroad with a Chicago address and have had Medicare and Mutual of Omaha Plan G for two years. Should I keep Medicare but switch to high-deductible Plan G for lower premiums despite preexisting conditions and required underwriting?

Answered by 8 licensed agents

This is a situation where I would be cautious about changing your current Medicare Supplement Plan G, especially with preexisting medical conditions.

First, Medicare generally does not cover healthcare received outside the United States. Plan G does include limited foreign travel emergency coverage, but that protection generally applies only during the first 60 days of a trip abroad. If you're living overseas long-term, that benefit may not help you.

Second, switching to High-Deductible Plan G could lower your monthly premium, but it increases your financial responsibility. In 2027, the annual high deductible is $3,050 before the supplement begins paying its regular benefits.

Here's something important about Illinois: If you're between ages 65 and 75, Illinois has a birthday enrollment rule allowing eligible Medicare Supplement policyholders to switch to a plan with equal or lesser benefits through the same insurance company or an affiliated insurer without medical underwriting during the 45 days beginning on their birthday.

That means your preexisting conditions might not prevent a switch. However, your actual Illinois residency, eligibility, and the availability of High-Deductible Plan G through Mutual of Omaha would need to be verified. Simply maintaining a Chicago mailing address does not establish residency.

My recommendation: Don't cancel your current Plan G until you've confirmed eligibility and been approved for replacement coverage.

I'd also consider how frequently you return to the United States for healthcare. Keeping Medicare Part B may make sense if you expect to return, since dropping it could result in enrollment delays and lifetime penalties if you later need it again.

The best decision depends on your age, current premium, expected time abroad, and plans for returning to the United States. Lower premiums are attractive, but protecting your future healthcare options is equally important.

Answered by Jon Cavanaugh on November 16, 2026

Broker Licensed in NV

Answered by Jon Cavanaugh Medicare Insurance Agent
I would be careful about switching just to save on premiums.

Original Medicare generally doesn't cover care while you're living abroad, and Plan G's foreign travel benefit is limited to certain emergencies during the first 60 days of a trip.

High-deductible Plan G may have a lower monthly premium, but you would pay more out of pocket before the supplement starts covering costs. In 2027, the deductible is $3,050.

Illinois does have a special 45-day window starting on your birthday for eligible Medigap policyholders ages 65 through 75 to move to equal or lesser coverage with the same insurer or an affiliate without medical underwriting.

Because you're living overseas, I would first confirm your residency and eligibility with the insurer. I would also consider how often you return to the U.S., compare the total costs, and never cancel your current Plan G until a replacement has been approved and is ready to take effect.

Answered by Nicoletta Catalucci on November 15, 2026

Broker Licensed in FL, MD, NC & 5 other states

Answered by Nicoletta Catalucci Medicare Insurance Agent
I’d keep your current Plan G in place while you explore the switch. Original Medicare generally offers very limited coverage outside the U.S., and Plan G’s foreign travel benefit is for qualifying emergencies during travel. If you live abroad, I’d ask Mutual of Omaha how your current policy applies and whether you’re eligible for a new policy based on where you actually live.

If you expect to return to the U.S. for care, I’d be cautious about dropping Part B because re-enrolling later could mean a delay or a late-enrollment penalty. If you’re considering High-Deductible Plan G, compare the annual premium savings with what you could pay before the policy starts paying. With underwriting required, keep your current policy until the new insurer approves you in writing and confirms the effective date.

Answered by Michelle Kim on November 16, 2026

Agent Licensed in VA & MD

Answered by Michelle Kim Medicare Insurance Agent
No, you will pay more out-of-pocket costs for the high-deductible plan vs. the plan premium

. For example: I have a client he wanted a supplement and a lower premium with a high-deductible plan G, by the time the year went by he paid 3850 for the deductible, and if he had been on the reg G with only a premium and a Part B deductible, he would of paid out a lot less by the end of the year. Needless to say, he has switched to the regular plan G for the new year.

Answered by JoAnna Jackson on November 14, 2026

Agent Licensed in MS

Answered by JoAnna Jackson Medicare Insurance Agent
Medicare does not cover Medicare beneficiaries when living abroad, except in some very unusual circumstances. If Medicare does not cover you, then the supplement will not cover you. If you return to the US, you have an SEP to choose a new plan.

Answered by Cindy Dedini on November 16, 2026

Broker Licensed in CA, AZ, CO & 11 other states

Answered by Cindy Dedini Medicare Insurance Agent
If you live abroad you can't use Medicare and by default your supplement won't have anything to pay. If you are worried about not being able to be covered if you come back to the USA ,than you need to decide if the deductible makes sense. HDG is a lot less expensive.

Answered by Dean Chiapetto on November 17, 2026

Broker Licensed in VA, MD, NC, TN & WV

Answered by Dean Chiapetto Medicare Insurance Agent
No, it is not guaranteed that you would be approved for the plan G high deductible . You can look at a plan G with a lower premium

Answered by Vanessa Costa on November 16, 2026

Agent Licensed in NJ, AR, AZ & 26 other states

Answered by Vanessa Costa Medicare Insurance Agent
If you are looking to lower your premium I can help you weight out anll your options whether it be a different supplement plan or Medicare Advantage plan. Contact me. Thank you, Tara LeSage

Answered by Tara LeSage on November 16, 2026

Broker Licensed in CA

Answered by Tara LeSage Medicare Insurance Agent

Tags: Advice for Seniors Coverage The Medicare System

Agents: Share Your Expertise

Have insights or experiences related to this topic? Help others by sharing your knowledge and answering this question.

Seniors: Ask a Question of Your Own

Questions are generally answered within 1 to 3 business days. Receive valuable perspectives from multiple licensed agents and brokers.

Ask a Question