How do I find a trustworthy Medicare agent in my area?

Question

Tamela Clayton · Accepted Answer

A good Medicare agent should focus on education first, not pressure. 
Look for someone who asks about your doctors, prescriptions, and budget, explains your options in plain language, and is available year‑round, not just during enrollment season. 
You can check online reviews, ask friends or your pharmacy for referrals, and make sure the agent is licensed in your state and represents multiple plan options, not just one company.”

Diondra Newton · Answer

To find a trustworthy Medicare agent in your area, try searching your local Facebook groups or NextDoor app for recommendations. Once you find someone that you believe has potential, contact them and set up an appointment (in-person or virtually). If they take the time to educate you (if needed), answer your questions and do not pressure you to make quick decisions about your coverage, you have most likely found your next agent!

Answered by Diondra Newton on May 11, 2026

Broker Licensed in FL

Answered by Diondra Newton Medicare Insurance Agent

Beverly Felchlin · Answer

A good way to find a trustworthy Medicare agent is to look for someone who is licensed, experienced and willing to explain your options without pressuring you into a particular plan.
Make sure to choose an agent who is a "broker" which represents many plans in your area as well as doing a needs analysis to review your doctors, prescriptions, pharmacy and healthcare needs before recommending a plan; on top of that, providing ongoing service after enrollment to answer any questions or problems.

ShaLane Hertel · Answer

I recommend to meet with 2-3 agents who are local to you and see which one is the most comprehensive. Making a medicare decision should involve understanding your lifestyle as a whole and not just a monthly premium or network.

Answered by ShaLane Hertel on May 11, 2026

Agent Licensed in OR, CA, ID & WA

Answered by ShaLane Hertel Medicare Insurance Agent

Nancy Courser · Answer

Word of mouth, ask family friends, google Medicare Agents in your area, attend seminars to learn more about Medicare and request a consultation from the agent (no cost to you).

Alexis Pepple · Answer

It is so important to work with an agent that is a career agent, so many agents capitalize during the major enrollment periods and are never heard from again. I recommend looking at Google Reviews, those are clients that are telling you who is great to work with. Also, brokers can be licensed in multiple states, having someone local is nice but having a great agent it more important! Pepple Insurance is here to help, we are you Medicare Concierge.

Answered by Alexis Pepple on May 18, 2026

Broker Licensed in CO, AK, AL & 38 other states

Answered by Alexis Pepple Medicare Insurance Agent

Jennifer Wesolek · Answer

I recommend reaching out to social media to see if you can get reviews or simply go in and talk to an agent, get a feel for if they will be honest with you and provide you truthful comparisons of not only supplements to MA plans but the Summary of benefits associated with each MA plan

Answered by Jennifer Wesolek on May 11, 2026

Agent Licensed in KY

Answered by Jennifer Wesolek Medicare Insurance Agent

Zachary Whitaker · Answer

Ask a trusted friend or family member, but always check their Google reviews! Reviews can't be taken down by the individual who wrote them.

Daniel Sawicki · Answer

The best way is to ask someone you know. Find out what they though and if they felt the agent really helped them or just sold them.

Laurie Baumgartner · Answer

word of mouth is usually the best. Visit with family and friends.

or finding an agent on Medicare Agents Hub

Janet Cruz · Answer

You meet with a couple and see which one makes you feel comfortable and trust worthy. Sometimes google reviews are not honest.

Charise Karjala · Answer

This answer is provided in a video format. Watch the agent's video response here: https://medicareagentshub.com/questions/how-do-i-find-a-trustworthy-medicare-agent-in-my-area#charise-karjala