Shrewsbury, PA Local Medicare Insurance Agents

Medicare Agents Hub in Shrewsbury, PA connects you with top local Medicare agents to help navigate your health insurance options as you turn 65 or update your current coverage. Our directory offers personalized assistance from knowledgeable Medicare brokers and advisors who understand the specific needs of the Shrewsbury community. Did you know that Shrewsbury is renowned for its charming historic district and the annual York County Olde Tyme Fair? Let us simplify your Medicare choices so you can enjoy everything this delightful town has to offer.

Top 8 Medicare Consultants Serving Shrewsbury, PA

The following featured Medicare Agents are top rated in Shrewsbury and throughout York County, PA. These local representatives are our picks as the best Medicare agents in Shrewsbury, and are ready to help you navigate all of the most important parts of signing up for Medicare.

Angela Erickson - Medicare Agent serving Shrewsbury, PA
Angela Erickson

#1 Top Rated Shrewsbury Broker

717-640-9457
Contact Angela
Kristy Hicks - Medicare Agent serving Shrewsbury, PA
Kristy Hicks

#2 Top Rated Shrewsbury Broker

717-640-9602
Contact Kristy
Will Schaeffer - Medicare Agent serving Shrewsbury, PA
Will Schaeffer

#3 Top Rated Shrewsbury Agent

443-312-1910
Contact Will
Greg Faulcon Jr. - Medicare Agent serving Shrewsbury, PA
Greg Faulcon Jr.

#4 Top Rated Shrewsbury Broker

410-489-1382
Contact Greg
Anthony Castelluccio - Medicare Agent serving Shrewsbury, PA
Anthony Castelluccio

#5 Top Rated Shrewsbury Agent

484-310-5375
Contact Anthony
John Hose - Medicare Agent serving Shrewsbury, PA
John Hose

#6 Top Rated Shrewsbury Broker

240-391-9799
Contact John
Linda McGill - Medicare Agent serving Shrewsbury, PA
Linda McGill

#7 Top Rated Shrewsbury Broker

703-997-9401
Contact Linda
Cory Weaver - Medicare Agent serving Shrewsbury, PA
Cory Weaver

#8 Top Rated Shrewsbury Broker

703-755-0625
Contact Cory

Local Shrewsbury Medicare Insurance Representatives by Distance

Barbara Barnes, CMIP® Medicare Agent Mount Wolf, PA 17347
Barbara Barnes, CMIP®

Barbara Barnes, CMIP®

  • Mount Wolf, PA 17347 (20 mi.)
John L Herman Jr Medicare Agent Licensed in PA
John L Herman Jr

Health Solutions Team

  • Licensed in PA (24 mi.)
Linwood Lane Medicare Agent York, PA 17403
Linwood Lane

Lane Insurance

  • York, PA 17403 (10 mi.)
Richard Costabile Medicare Agent York, PA 17403
Richard Costabile

Asset Protectors, LLC.

  • York, PA 17403 (10 mi.)
Raju Subedi Medicare Agent East York, PA 17402
Raju Subedi

  • East York, PA 17402 (13 mi.)
Patrick Lohrey Medicare Agent Weigelstown, PA 17408
Patrick Lohrey

Patrick X Lohrey

  • Weigelstown, PA 17408 (14 mi.)
Melissa Barnickel Medicare Agent Licensed in PA
Melissa Barnickel

Baygroup Insurance LLC

  • Licensed in PA (15 mi.)
Tessa Rill Medicare Agent Hanover, PA 17331
Tessa Rill

  • Hanover, PA 17331 (16 mi.)
Miranda Markowski Medicare Agent York, PA 17404
Miranda Markowski

  • York, PA 17404 (17 mi.)
Theresa Waltersdorff Medicare Agent York, PA 17406
Theresa Waltersdorff

ABI Insurance

  • York, PA 17406 (17 mi.)
Jamie Lagana Medicare Agent York, PA 17406
Jamie Lagana

  • York, PA 17406 (17 mi.)
Cheena Wolferd Medicare Agent Holtwood, PA 17532
Cheena Wolferd

Ace High Benefits

  • Holtwood, PA 17532 (19 mi.)
Barry Gerskov Medicare Agent Licensed in PA
Barry Gerskov

  • Licensed in PA (21 mi.)
Gerard Washington Medicare Agent Licensed in PA
Gerard Washington

  • Licensed in PA (21 mi.)
Larry Wright Medicare Agent Licensed in PA
Larry Wright

  • Licensed in PA (21 mi.)
Douglas Watts Medicare Agent Licensed in PA
Douglas Watts

  • Licensed in PA (21 mi.)

Refine Results Further by Zip Code

Looking for more specific results within Shrewsbury or Pennsylvania? Simply enter in your zip code for a full list of Medicare agents in your area.

Use our free online directory to find Medicare insurance agents in Shrewsbury zip code 17361.

MedicareAgentsHub.com also features licensed Medicare insurance brokers in nearby communities New Freedom, Stewartstown, Parkton, Dallastown, Red Lion, Spry, White Hall, Grantley, West York, and Manchester.

Why work with a local Shrewsbury Medicare Consultant?

Working with a local Medicare agent has many advantages over direct enrollment or working with a nation-wide agent.

  • Familiar with Shrewsbury: Local agents take extra time to understand your personal situation and understand what everyday life is like in York County.
  • Different Local Pricing: Medicare plan pricing can vary significantly by zip code. So the exact same plan in Shrewsbury might be a totally different price in New Freedom or Stewartstown. Local Medicare advisors can provide accurate quotes and help you compare and choose a local Medicare plan in real time.
  • Intimate Medicare Knowledge: Agents familiar with Shrewsbury plans will be able to explain everything you need to know about Medicare, without having to spend countless hours doing your own research. If you wish to learn more about Medicare prior to meeting with your agent, be sure to check out our list of Shrewsbury Medicare & Senior Resources.
Insurance Agents Offering Aetna Medicare Plans in Shrewsbury, PA
Insurance Agents Offering Anthem Medicare Plans in Shrewsbury, PA
Insurance Agents Offering Humana Medicare Plans in Shrewsbury, PA
Insurance Agents Offering UnitedHealthcare Medicare Plans in Shrewsbury, PA
Insurance Agents Offering Cigna Medicare Plans in Shrewsbury, PA
Insurance Agents Offering Mutual Medicare Plans in Shrewsbury, PA

Latest Medicare Insights From Agents

Helpful information and articles from top rated agents across the country to help you learn about Medicare as you are browsing for a Shrewsbury Medicare agent.

A Family Guide to Hospice and Medicare: What I Learned From My Mom’s Experience
Written by Michael Ferraro Medicare Insurance Agent
A Family Guide to Hospice and Medicare: What I Learned From My Mom’s Experience

Written by Michael Ferraro

I wasn’t prepared for what hospice meant until my mom needed it. This article shares what I learned about hospice care and how Medicare helps cover it, in hopes it can make things clearer for you and your family.

Pay Now or Pay Later: The Real Cost of Medicare Advantage vs. Medigap
Written by Todd Bostic Medicare Insurance Agent
Pay Now or Pay Later: The Real Cost of Medicare Advantage vs. Medigap

Written by Todd Bostic

Medicare Advantage plans may seem like a great deal with all their extras, but they often come with hidden costs when you actually need care. With Medigap, you pay more upfront each month, but you usually walk into a doctor or hospital and owe nothing.

Medicare in 2025: Must-Know Changes and Challenges for New and Current Enrollees
Written by Douglas Carney Medicare Insurance Agent
Medicare in 2025: Must-Know Changes and Challenges for New and Current Enrollees

Written by Douglas Carney

In 2025, Medicare’s transformative changes are sparking discussions among new and current enrollees. From cost-saving measures to privatization concerns, these shifts are reshaping healthcare planning. Here are the top trending topics you need to know, based on recent updates.

Local Resources for Seniors in Shrewsbury

Discover essential services for seniors in Shrewsbury, Pennsylvania. In addition to connecting seniors with Medicare insurance consultants in Shrewsbury, we've curated a selection of helpful links to local resources that provide information and community support for Shrewsbury seniors.

Pennsylvania Department of Aging

The Pennsylvania Department of Aging provides a wealth of services and information aimed at improving the quality of life for older Pennsylvanians. It offers comprehensive details on healthcare, insurance options (including Medicare), meal assistance, and much more. This resource is particularly valuable for individuals who are turning 65 or those already a part of the Medicare system.

Visit the Pennsylvania Department of Aging website »