Sharie Rutherford, Medicare Insurance Broker

About Me

With over 25 years as a licensed insurance broker, Sharie brings unmatched experience, energy, and heart to everything she does. As the founder of City Insurance Group, she proudly partners with more than 44 dedicated brokers who share her passion for helping people navigate the confusing world of Medicare.

Sharie is a true expert in Medicare insurance plans, with a strong background in Special Needs Plans (SNPs), Medicaid, and Low-Income Subsidy/Extra Help prescription drug programs. Her deep knowledge allows her to guide clients through even the most complex situations with clarity and confidence.

But what truly sets Sharie apart? She loves the connection with her clients. She believes everyone has something to teach her — and that belief shapes the way she connects, listens, and serves.

Sharie thrives on the personal side of her work. Helping people, educating them, and making Medicare feel less overwhelming is her favorite part of the job. Her guiding philosophy is simple: be an attentive listener and always do what’s right for the client.

If you're looking for someone who combines industry expertise with a truly personal touch — Sharie is the Medicare professional you can count on!

Get in touch with Sharie using this form

Directions to My Office

Google Logo

My Google Reviews

116 Total Reviews   (5.0 )

Profile Picture
Cyndi Harris
November 13, 2026

Sharie is so very helpful. Very knowledgeable, unbiased, and skilled. She takes the time to really hear your needs and provide you with information that meets that and helps you think broadly about your options.

Profile Picture
Ronald Phelps
November 13, 2026

Very professional, and knowledgeable

Profile Picture
Sandie Kensington
November 11, 2026

We have been using Sharie for a number of years as our advocate for finding health insurance coverage. She does an exceptional job and works diligently to find the best coverage for our needs.

Profile Picture
Robert Parfet
November 10, 2026

review current plan and compare

Profile Picture
Joseph Licata
November 10, 2026

This lady knows here stuff. She has been helping not only me and my family, but also a couple of friends and family. I would highly recommend her to anyone.

Q&A with Sharie Rutherford

Does Medicare cover Alzheimer's disease treatment?

Answer: Coverage depends on the service involved. Visits with doctors, neurologists, cognitive testing, brain scans are typically covered. Prescription medications can be very helpful and are covered if mild cognitive or early-stage Alzheimer's is diagnosed. Medicare, however, does not cover long-term custodial care like a memory care facility, which is one of the largest challenges families face. Resources are available for further understanding of this devastating disease.

What are the reasons why I should work with a Medicare agent?

Answer: Agents are able to drill down on intricacies that are often not available on websites or through 1-800 numbers. It's those fine details - provider nuances, formulary exceptions, networking considerations, underwriting guidelines, and real-world plan experiences - that can make the difference for a client.