Kaylie Nutter, Medicare Insurance Broker

About Me

Hello! I'm Kaylie, your trusted Medicare agent in the area. My specialty is Medicare, and I'm passionate about helping you select the ideal plan that caters to your individual needs and budget. I'll efficiently sort through plans from reputable national and local companies, saving you time and effort. Best of all, my services are provided at no cost to you. Contact me to discuss your Medicare choices and don't forget to mention that you found me on Medicare Agents Hub!

Get in touch with Kaylie using this form

Google Logo

My Google Reviews

2509 Total Reviews   (5.0 )

Profile Picture
David Laing
November 9, 2026

Kaylie Nutter: was nothing but professional. Exceptional! Extremely well rehearsed and informed on her expertise. Percent

Profile Picture
Donna Hagenbuch
January 30, 2026

Kaylee helped me to choose insurance that was right for me. She was very helpful, polite and patient. Kaylee was very knowledgeable.

Profile Picture
Herb Flint
July 1, 2025

Both Ashley and Kallie were courteous, professional and caring as it concerned my personal health insurance needs. I felt cared for and that they had my best interest at heart. I am very happy with the end result.

Profile Picture
JOHN STEALEY
November 20, 2024

Kaylee has been very helpful and extremely patient throughout this entire process. You better figure out a way to keep her.

Profile Picture
Johnny Parker
October 13, 2023

Kaylie is a very pleasant and courteous agent who was very helpful in providing advice to me about my plan"s OTC benefits.

Q&A with Kaylie Nutter

Does Medicare cover SilverSneakers?

Answer: Original Medicare on its own doesn't cover SilverSneakers or other gym memberships. That said, a lot of Medicare Advantage plans include it, and some Medicare Supplement plans offer it as an extra perk. If staying active at the gym matters to you, let your agent know so they can filter for plans that include a fitness benefit in your area.

Does Medicare have a deductible?

Answer: Yes, and there are a few different ones. Part A has a deductible for each hospital benefit period, Part B has a yearly deductible before it starts paying 80% for doctor and outpatient care, and many Part D drug plans have their own deductible too. Medicare Advantage plans set their own cost sharing, and some have no medical deductible at all, so it really depends on how you're set up.

What are Special Needs Plans (SNPs) in Medicare Advantage?

Answer: Special Needs Plans are Medicare Advantage plans built for specific groups of people. There are three types: D-SNPs for people who have both Medicare and Medicaid, C-SNPs for people living with certain chronic conditions like diabetes or heart failure, and I-SNPs for people who live in a nursing home or need that level of care at home. They include prescription coverage and usually add care coordination, and many D-SNPs come with extra benefits like grocery or over-the-counter allowances.

Are there any pointers or suggestions when looking over my ANOC (Annual Notice of Change)?

Answer: Start with the first page or two, which summarize what's changing, then go straight to the sections on your premium, your drug list, and your doctor network. I always tell clients to check whether any of their prescriptions moved to a higher tier or now need prior authorization, because that's where surprise costs usually show up. Compare the new maximum out-of-pocket and copays to this year's numbers, and if anything looks worse, that's your cue to shop during the fall enrollment period.