Allen McGirl, Medicare Insurance Broker


About Me

Allen McGirl is a trusted Medicare advisor and the President of McGirl Insurance, serving individuals and families in Englewood, Denver, and communities across the Denver Metro area—and nationwide—for over 30 years.

Since 1995, Allen has helped thousands of clients confidently navigate Medicare by simplifying complex decisions and providing clear, personalized guidance. He specializes in Medicare Advantage, Medicare Supplement (Medigap) plans, and Part D prescription drug coverage, ensuring each client understands their options and avoids costly mistakes.

As a recognized Medicare expert in Colorado, Allen is known for his educational approach. He regularly hosts Medicare 101 workshops and community events to help individuals turning 65—or already on Medicare—make informed decisions with confidence. His mission is simple: to remove confusion, protect clients from coverage gaps, and help them choose plans that align with their healthcare needs and financial goals.

McGirl Insurance is an independent Medicare brokerage based in Englewood, Colorado, representing a wide range of top-rated insurance carriers. This allows Allen and his team to offer unbiased recommendations tailored specifically to each client.

In addition to Medicare, Allen and his team also assist with supplemental insurance plans including cancer, heart attack, and stroke coverage, as well as life insurance, under-65 health plans, and group benefits for businesses.

If you're searching for a knowledgeable, local Medicare agent in Englewood, Denver, Cherry Creek, Littleton, or nationwide, Allen McGirl is a trusted resource dedicated to helping you make the right decision—without pressure. Licensed in 40 states.

Get in touch with Allen using this form

Directions to My Office

Google Logo

My Google Reviews

142 Total Reviews   (4.9 )

Profile Picture
Susie Christensen
June 8, 2026

Allen is super! Whenever I have a question or problem, he has been there to explain or solve my problem. I moved to Tennessee recently and he is able to serve me there too. He is very knowledgable and I highly recommend him for Medicare coverage/insurance assistance.

Profile Picture
Jodi Vinterella
June 6, 2026

Allen is the best at what he does. Highly recommend his firm.

Profile Picture
Janet Cott
June 5, 2026

Very helpful and explained my Medicare options well. Plus, I didn't feel like he was just a salesman.

Profile Picture
Denise Stuart
June 4, 2026

I highly recommend McGirl Insurance. As a broker, Allen McGirl is extremely knowledgeable, patient, and took the time to explain all Medicare options in a way we could understand. Not only do I recommend our patients use McGirl Insurance, but my family does too.

Profile Picture
Connie Johns
June 3, 2026

Q&A with Allen McGirl

Answer: It depends on the State and your Medicare Part B effective date. If you are in a non-guarantee issue State and have had another Medicare Supplement plan longer than 6 months, then you would need to answer health questions to qualify. Contact us to see if you qualify.

Answer: Due to lack of funding from the Government and lack of planning on the insurance company are some reasons seniors are losing coverages.

Answer: You should try and qualify for Low Income Subsidy or Medicaid by going to ssa.gov/prescriptionhelp. We provide this service at no charge to all out clients and prospects.

Answer: We shall see. Raised rates yearly will determine this. Costs are important and many people may not be able to afford it.

Answer: It all depends on the plan you choose. Not all plans have this and some have plans similar. Be sure to check your plan benefits and ask the correct questions.

Answer: It depends if you have coverage through your employer and if they have more or less than 20 employees. It is important to speak to an agent like myself to help you understand your options.

Answer: Climate change-related health issues are increasingly expected to affect Medicare policy because older adults are among the most vulnerable populations during extreme weather events, poor air quality, and infectious disease outbreaks.

Answer: If you miss the main Medicare Open Enrollment Period, you may still have options depending on your situation and the type of change you want to make.

Main Enrollment Windows

Medicare Annual Enrollment Period (AEP)

October 15 – December 7

You can:

switch Medicare Advantage plans,

move from Medicare Advantage to Original Medicare,

join/change/drop Part D drug plans.

Coverage changes start January 1.

Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment Period (MA OEP)

January 1 – March 31

If you already have a Medicare Advantage plan, you can:

switch to another Medicare Advantage plan once,

or return to Original Medicare and add Part D.

You cannot switch from Original Medicare to Medicare Advantage during this window.

If You Missed Both

You may still qualify for a Special Enrollment Period (SEP).

Common SEP triggers include:

Moving to a new service area

Losing employer or union coverage

Medicaid eligibility changes

Qualifying for Extra Help

Moving into or out of a nursing facility

Plan termination by the carrier

FEMA or disaster-related issues

Gaining or losing a Special Needs Plan condition

Recently leaving incarceration

Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services allows SEPs for many life events, but the rules and timelines vary.

Answer: The biggest disadvantage of Medicare Advantage for many people is usually network restrictions and prior authorization requirements compared with Original Medicare.

With most Medicare Advantage plans (especially HMOs and PPOs):

You may need to use specific doctors, hospitals, and specialists.

Out-of-network care can be limited or much more expensive.

Some services require prior authorization before the plan approves payment.

That can become a major issue if:

you travel often,

want access to top specialty hospitals nationwide,

develop a serious illness,

or your doctors leave the network.

Answer: Not necessarily. Medicare can provide strong coverage, but it often works differently than employer-sponsored insurance, and there can be gaps depending on which Medicare option you choose.

Answer: Medicare Part A is primarily funded through payroll taxes from current workers.

As the population ages, the number of beneficiaries grows faster than the workforce paying into the system.

People are also living longer and using more healthcare services, especially hospital and skilled nursing care.

Answer: Original Medicare does not cover you outside of the United States. Some Medicare Supplement and Advantage plans may cover Emergencies, but you should consider purchasing a travel policy from my website.

Answer: If you have plan F, then your Medicare part A started before Jan 1, 2020. Plan F does not have a copay or deductible for Part A or B. You will only pay a premium and your emergency visit is covered 100%

Answer: If a senior does not take Medicare when first eligible or do not have credible health insurance to waive Medicare, then you may incur penalties for the rest of your life.

Answer: NO, This is not true. Medicare does not pay for any dental vision or hearing unless it falls under medical in which it may be covered under part B.

Answer: This is a bummer. You can go online and order a new one. Call Medicare and order one. We help people log in and do it for them.

Answer: I ask them to complete a Medicare review form. I want to know all your doctors, hospitals, prescriptions and the pharmacy you use. This will help me educate you on your options.

Answer: Work with an agent to review your drugs on Medicare.gov. Also, you have the right to use Good RX or any other source. Some folks use Canadian Meds. There are many options, but the money you spend on these programs do not go toward your catastrophic amount. So sometimes, not advised.

Answer: The federal Government subsidizes Medicare Advantage plans. The insurance companies create plans with the money to offer a $0 premium plan that includes copay, coinsurance and possible deductibles.

Answer: Medicare is complicated and if you do not work with a true professional who educates you on ALL options, then you could make a big mistake when you need medical care. I have helped thousands of people the past 30 years and I help educate and enroll a person on the plan they chose once they have all the information.

Answer: Ultimately, your doctor is making these decisions. However, it depends on what plan you have and what the procedure is. There are a couple of factors you need to be aware of. Prior authorization and preapprovals within Medicare Advantage plans. Not so much with Original Medicare, but five States as of 2026 are required to use Prior Authorization on some procedures. Reach out to me for more information.